For over 450 years (literally), St. Augustine has been one of Florida’s most sought-after destinations, blending centuries of history with miles of pristine shoreline. But, alas, gone are the days of sailing from Spain, sticking a flag in the ground, and claiming the land for your king. Finding your prime piece of land in St. Augustine is as rewarding as ever, if not slightly more complex.
Even without a royal mandate, the city offers two distinct opportunities for homebuyers and investors: waterfront living along the beaches and rivers, or the historic charm of cobblestone streets and historic homes. Both options come with unique benefits and challenges, leaving many to wonder: which is the smarter investment?
Why St. Augustine Real Estate?
Now, before we go any further, we would like to say that the number one reason anyone should buy real estate in St. Augustine is because it truly is the greatest place in the world. We firmly believe that, and it’s no coincidence that we went to college in town and have been putting down roots in this sandy soil ever since.
Pull back the curtain and you’ll quickly see St. Augustine is more than America’s oldest city. What you’ll discover, like those explorers before you, is a thriving real estate market with strong tourism, steady relocation trends, and enduring appeal. From families relocating for quality of life to retirees seeking coastal living and investors searching for high-demand rentals, the market here is diverse. The blend of historic charm and natural beauty makes it a top contender for both long-term ownership and short-term rental opportunities.
The Allure of Waterfront Properties
Lifestyle Benefits
Waterfront living in St. Augustine offers an unmatched lifestyle. Imagine waking up to ocean views on Anastasia Island, fishing along the Matanzas River, or watching sunsets in Vilano Beach. Or, if you’re like us, bringing your favorite four-legged friend along for sunrise surf sessions. Waterfront homes bring direct access to boating, paddleboarding, and beach walks, creating an everyday sense of relaxation and escape.
Investment Potential
Waterfront properties consistently perform well in the investment market. With St. Augustine’s growing reputation as a vacation destination, oceanfront and riverfront homes are highly sought-after for short-term rentals. Luxury homes along the Intracoastal and beaches often see strong appreciation, especially as waterfront land becomes increasingly scarce. Our personal favorite is the exclusive street of Atlantic View. If you see a property pop up here that you like, give us a call immediately because they do not last long!
Considerations
Investors should also weigh the realities of waterfront ownership. Flood insurance premiums can add significant costs, and maintenance expenses run higher due to salt air, humidity, and storm exposure. While the lifestyle and ROI can be impressive, these factors require careful planning.
The Charm of Historic Properties
Lifestyle Benefits
Downtown St. Augustine offers a completely different, yet equally appealing, way of life. Living among the historic homes means stepping outside to brick-lined streets, charming boutiques, award-winning restaurants (there is no beating the quality of Llama Restaurant and Collage is simply the best), and year-round festivals. The walkability and cultural vibrancy are unmatched, attracting those who value community and authenticity.
Investment Potential
Historic district properties carry strong investment value. Tourists are drawn to the city’s history, and vacation rentals within walking distance of St. George Street, the Castillo de San Marcos, and Flagler College are in high demand. Resale values remain steady, as these homes are unique and limited in supply.
Considerations
With charm comes responsibility. Many historic homes fall under preservation codes, limiting certain renovations or exterior changes. Maintenance can also be higher, as older homes often require specialized repairs. For investors, this means factoring in additional time and costs.
Comparing the Two: Waterfront vs. Historic Charm
Target Audience & Tenant Profile
Waterfront: Appeals to vacationers, retirees, and second-home buyers who prioritize lifestyle and views.
Historic: Attracts culture-focused tourists and long-term residents who value walkability and authenticity.
Appreciation & ROI
Waterfront: Strong appreciation, especially in luxury coastal markets. High demand for vacation rentals.
Historic: Steady appreciation with niche demand. Strong occupancy rates in rental properties due to cultural appeal.
Lifestyle Match
Waterfront: Outdoor living, boating, and relaxation.
Historic: Arts, dining, and immersion in history.
Tips for Making the Right Investment
-
Clarify your goals: Is the property primarily for personal enjoyment, short-term rental income, or long-term appreciation?
-
Work with a local St. Augustine real estate expert (like us!) who understands zoning laws, preservation codes, and flood regulations.
-
Balance ROI with lifestyle — the best investment is often the one that fits your personal vision for life in the Nation’s Oldest City.
Whether it’s the sound of waves on Anastasia Island or the timeless beauty of a Victorian home downtown, St. Augustine offers investment opportunities that fit every vision. Waterfront properties deliver luxury and strong appreciation, while historic homes provide cultural richness and steady rental demand. The right choice depends on your financial goals, risk tolerance, and lifestyle dreams.
Take the Next Step in Your Real Estate Journey with The Newcomer Group
The best part about this debate? There is no right or wrong answer! Give us a call today at (904) 201-9393 to discover whether waterfront living or historic charm is the best fit for your investment.
